home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=91TT1034>
- <title>
- May 13, 1991: A Happy Birthday for The Kids of Kane
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1991
- May 13, 1991 Crack Kids
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- CINEMA, Page 69
- A Happy Birthday for The Kids of Kane
- </hdr><body>
- <p>From somewhere beyond the fringe of Hollywood, four cult classics
- emerge, trashing tired formulas and challenging the way we see
- movies
- </p>
- <p>By RICHARD CORLISS
- </p>
- <p> Fifty years ago last week, Hollywood was the home of the
- avant garde. RKO released an experimental film made by a
- 25-year-old novice who didn't know the rules, didn't care when
- his studio elders said, "You can't do that!" Outrageous,
- iconoclastic, with warning shadows and baroque camera angles,
- Citizen Kane told future moviemakers that anything was possible.
- If you were Orson Welles.
- </p>
- <p> Alas, a career full of lost skirmishes with the moguls
- proved that even Welles couldn't shake Hollywood free of its
- romantic realism. It held then; it holds today. Except that now
- the old glamour has atrophied into formula: boy's adventures and
- ghost stories and lady-in-distress thrillers. When was the last
- time a Hollywood picture moved anyone to exclaim, "Well, I've
- never seen that before!"? Perhaps surprise is not on the menu
- of today's moviegoers. They want reassurance, domestic fairy
- tales come true, not the astonishment that Jean Cocteau demanded
- of art.
- </p>
- <p> So all hail the American fringies, those young filmmakers
- who make something different out of next to nothing. These fine
- artists must also be slick salesmen. They scrounge for five,
- six, seven years to get funding--because it's harder to raise
- money for a $90,000 no-star feature than it is for a $90
- million Schwarzenepic--and then scrape at the doors of
- independent distributors. They should win an Irving Thalberg
- award just for persistence.
- </p>
- <p> But you shouldn't go to a movie just because a director
- tried hard. There are plenty of independent films whose
- ambitions point only toward conventional story telling. It
- happens that there are four new movies aiming higher, farther,
- stranger. And they won't be mistaken for Home Alone or even The
- Long Walk Home. Call them off-Hollywood movies, because they
- have sworn off Hollywood.
- </p>
- <p> With POISON, Todd Haynes has people swearing at him--the
- right people, if you're looking for notoriety. Donald Wildmon,
- head of the right-wing American Family Association, has
- condemned Haynes' film for its "porno scenes of homosexuals."
- And the Advocate, a gay biweekly, has reported that the campaign
- against Poison was stoked by White House chief of staff John
- Sununu in hopes of embarrassing John Frohnmayer, chairman of the
- National Endowment for the Arts, which helped fund the film.
- </p>
- <p> Haynes dines on controversy. His previous picture was the
- rough, wickedly funny Superstar: The Karen Carpenter Story, a
- sort of Valley of the Dolls (but with real dolls) that was
- suppressed by the Carpenter family. Poison is a more somber
- affair. The shock comes not from any graphic sex, for there is
- none, but from the pristine virtuosity of Haynes' craft. In
- three interlocking stories inspired by Jean Genet, this
- homoerotic Intolerance details the toxicity of prejudice, fear
- and disease, as played out in a tumid hothouse of forbidden
- sexual longing. A scientist who turns leprous when he drinks a
- sex potion; a prisoner who finds brief orgasmic release, and
- pays for it; a child who kills his abusive father--all are
- outcasts, poison to society. Only the child escapes, jumping
- from a window and soaring into his idea of heaven: oblivion.
- </p>
- <p> Anonymity would be death to the heavenly creatures on
- parade in PARIS IS BURNING, Jennie Livingston's thrilling
- documentary. They are the gentlemen of the Harlem drag balls.
- They wear frocks to die for; they vogue on the floor like
- Madonna dancers. A few have passed beyond show biz. A frail
- baby-voiced blond named Venus Xtravaganza says, "I wanna be a
- rich, pampered white woman," as she curls up in a tacky bedroom
- furnished only by her dreams.
- </p>
- <p> Livingston could have settled for the ethnographic camp of
- the ball contests: a gay Pumping Iron, drenched in primping
- irony. Instead she found eloquent people with a fine sense of
- their flair and vulnerability. Paris Is Burning is a bijou hit
- in New York City and will be elsewhere, as audiences realize
- that the voguers are camera-worthy not because of their
- flamboyance but because of their home-truth humanity. As one of
- them says, "You've left a mark on the world if you just get
- through it."
- </p>
- <p> Nobody will get through BEGOTTEN without being marked. In
- this nightmare classic by Edmund Elias Merhige, a godlike thing
- dies giving birth to a womanly thing, who gives birth to a
- quivering messiah thing; then the local villager things ravage
- and bury them, and the earth renews itself on their corpses. It
- is as if a druidical cult had re-enacted, for real, three Bible
- stories--creation, the Nativity and Jesus' torture and death
- on Golgotha--and some demented genius were there to film it.
- No names, no dialogue, no compromises, no exit. No apologies
- either, for Begotten is a spectacular one-of-a-kind (you
- wouldn't want there to be two), filmed in speckled chiaroscuro
- so that each image is a seductive mystery, a Rorschach test for
- the adventurous eye.
- </p>
- <p> In WATER AND POWER, Pat O'Neill takes us even deeper into
- post-narrative. His is an abstract film in a rush--a universe
- of images in 57 hurtling minutes. He can't wait for the moon to
- rise; with time-lapse photography he Frisbees it into the sky.
- He tells the history of Western expansion in one minute, with
- subtitles and sound effects. And he isn't satisfied with man or
- nature. Flames of neon lick the clouds; an electric fan helps
- cool the desert.
- </p>
- <p> The subject is familiar from Chinatown: Los Angeles has
- its water piped in from afar; the archetypal modern city is
- built on the theft of age-old resources. Godfrey Reggio's
- Koyaanisqatsi (1983) had the same doomsday message dressed in
- high-tech style. That movie was serious fun, but O'Neill's is
- bolder, more disciplined. Every shot has a lure and a meaning;
- the film's shapely silhouette is easy to trace. Gorgeous and
- zippy, Water and Power is an intoxicant without a hangover.
- </p>
- <p> None of these films are Citizen Kane--what is?--but
- they come close to the spirit and intent of that eternally
- young masterpiece. They treat film technique as a living
- language; they taunt, dazzle, delight. Best of all, they seem
- ready to spawn a receptive audience. On a spring afternoon in
- Manhattan, hundreds of smart-setters crowd the lobbies of the
- Film Forum and the Angelika, downtown temples of alternative
- film. Poison and Paris Is Burning are sold out hours in advance.
- The atmosphere is festive, with the feeling that something good
- might happen inside. The movies, all movies, could use a
- transfusion of hope.
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-